Hypogenic
Overprinting, Radionuclide Activity and Diurnal Ventilation: Redrawing the
Foundations of Speleothem-Based Paleoclimate Reconstructions
Mike Buchanan 2025
Abstract
Introduction
Caves are considered ideal archives of paleoclimate by some
due to their stable environments and alleged ability to preserve mineral
deposits over millennia. Speleothem such as stalagmites and flowstone are
believed to provide high-resolution records of isotopic data, trace elements
and growth dynamics, offering insights into past temperature, rainfall and
vegetation regimes. Yet, the oversimplified treatment of cave systems as
closed, thermally inert and continuously epigenic environments has overlooked
the complexities introduced by airflow dynamics, subsurface radionuclide
activity, microbial speleogenesis and primarily hypogenic speleogenesis.
Immediate Cave Climatology: Real-Time Dynamics
Immediate cave climatology refers to the short-term
microclimatic conditions that regulate cave atmosphere, chemistry, and
morphology. These dynamics unfold on daily to seasonal timescales and
profoundly influence speleothem growth, gas exchange, and microbial ecology.
a) Temperature Regulation
Caves maintain thermal equilibrium close to the regional
mean annual surface temperature. In Gauteng, South Africa, for example, caves
remain around 17°C year-round, rarely fluctuating more than ±1°C. This is due
to the thermal inertia of surrounding rock and limited direct surface exposure
(Gregorič et al., 2013).
b) Diurnal Ventilation
Ventilation cycles occur when external ambient temperatures
differ from the cave's mean. Cooler night air flows inward ("breathing
in"), while warmer daytime air pushes internal air outward
("breathing out") (Sánchez-Cañete et al., 2013). This daily breathing
facilitates CO₂, radon, and moisture exchange without significantly altering
cave temperature.
c) Humidity and Particulate Deposition
Humidity in caves typically approaches saturation (95–100%),
with minimal fluctuation. Small temperature shifts can trigger
condensation-evaporation cycles, influencing:
- Speleothem
dissolution or precipitation.
- Wall
and ceiling corrosion features.
- Biological
activity, especially fungal and microbial communities.
Organic particulates (e.g., hair, lint, skin) from tourists
accumulate and influence condensation nuclei formation, subtly modifying
speleothem growth conditions in high-traffic areas.
d) Human Influence on Cave Microclimate
Tourist caves undergo thermal, chemical, and physical
modification. Visitors introduce CO₂, metabolic heat and organic aerosols,
which can increase cave-air CO₂ concentrations and reduce the gradient driving
CO₂ degassing from water and soils. Foot-traffic–induced substrate compaction
alters airflow and water infiltration, inhibiting speleothem growth and causing
localised ecological degradation or relict conditions. Compaction and
disturbance reduce soil porosity and displace or destroy microbial and invertebrate
communities that contribute to local biogeochemical fluxes and small-scale heat
production. Although biological heat production is minor relative to visitor
metabolic heat and external thermal inputs, loss of these communities can
measurably alter microclimate, gas fluxes, and nutrient cycling in affected
zones. The magnitude and persistence of these effects depend on cave geometry,
ventilation regime, visitor numbers, timing and hydrological connectivity.
e) Barometric Pressure and Radon Interplay
Radon (²²²Rn) concentrations respond to pressure changes and
airflow rates. During stable atmospheric conditions, radon accumulates; during
ventilation events, it is flushed dependant on luminal flow volumes. Elevated
temperatures accelerate radon emanation from host rock, increasing ionizing
radiation and influencing microbial populations including mineral dissolution
(Šrámek et al., 2015).
These real-time processes define the cave's living climate
and challenge the perception of subterranean environments as static.
Ventilation modulates CO₂ levels within the cave atmosphere,
which directly affects the degassing of drip water and subsequent
calcite/aragonite precipitation. High ventilation (typically in winter) lowers
cave air CO₂, increasing degassing and speleothem growth. Conversely, low
ventilation (summer) conditions reduce degassing potential (de Freitas and
Littlejohn, 1987).
Furthermore, high visitor activity introduces additional CO₂
and particulate matter such as hair, skin cells or sloughing and lint. These
organic and inorganic particulates function as nucleation substrates for
speleothem growth, particularly in tourist caves. Over time, this can sterilise
active formations, converting them into relict speleothems by compacting
substrate layers and elevating CO₂ beyond saturation thresholds.
4. Radionuclides and Cave Speleogenesis
Radon (²²²Rn) levels in caves fluctuate with temperature,
pressure, and airflow. In Seongryu Cave, Korea, night-time accumulation and
daytime flushing of radon provide clear evidence of diurnal ventilation (Oh
& Kim, 2011). Temperature indirectly affects radon emanation by influencing
diffusion and airflow efficiency. The hotter the cave, the more radon is
released due to accelerated emanation rates and increased decay kinetics.
Radionuclides contribute to speleogenesis via several
pathways:
- Alpha
recoil: Damage from alpha decay of U-series isotopes increases rock
susceptibility to dissolution.
- Radiolysis:
Decay-induced splitting of water molecules produces reactive radicals
(OH•, H•) {hydroxyl radical & hydrogen radical} that enhance chemical
weathering.
- Microbial
mediation: Radionuclide-rich environments foster chemo lithotrophic
microbial communities that catalyse rock dissolution (Šrámek et al.,
2015).
These mechanisms introduce non-climatic drivers of
speleothem development, particularly in confined karst systems with limited
ventilation. Radon and its daughters of decay contribute to long-term chemical
instability, creating isotopic noise that can mask or mimic environmental
signals.
5. Hypogenic Overprinting and Isotopic Clock Reset
Hypogenic speleogenesis involves the action of ascending fluids, often enriched
in CO₂ or H₂S, which can intrude vadose cave systems and trigger episodes of
rapid mineral precipitation successively. A single hypogenic event, occurring
on centennial to millennial scales, may deposit massive quantities of calcite,
overprinting or super saturating pre-existing speleothem layers and obscuring
fine-scale isotopic signals (δ¹⁸O, δ¹³C). This process compromises the apparent
continuity of laminar growth and risks misleading paleoclimate interpretations
if not detected through petrographic or geochemical screening (Klimchouk, 2007;
Palmer, 2007).
Such events may also induce open-system behavior in uranium-series isotopes,
leading to partial or complete resetting of U-Th isotopic systems. This
undermines one of the primary chronological tools used in speleothem research
(Edwards et al., 1987; Dorale & Liu, 2009). Consequently, speleothem
subjected to hypogenic overprinting may yield chronologies that appear precise
but are in fact compromised, masking or homogenising environmental signals.
Without careful petrographic and geochemical assessment, these archives risk
being misinterpreted as continuous records of climatic change when they are
instead overprinted by non-climatic events.
In such cases, the appearance of continuous laminar growth
may be deceptive. Without petrographic or trace-element screening, researchers
risk interpreting homogenised, event-driven speleothem as representative
climate records (Klimchouk, 2007; Palmer, 2007; Dorale & Liu, 2009). More
critically, the assumption of isotopic continuity fails in hypogenic contexts.
Supersaturation over even a short span (e.g., one hundred years) can obliterate
the resolution of δ¹⁸O and δ¹³C records and flatten trace element variability.
In doing so, the speleothem becomes a homogenised, non-climatic archive. These
overprints could reset uranium-series ages, rendering the chronological
framework speculative.
6. Implications for Paleoclimate Reconstructions
Speleothem archives have underpinned thousands of
paleoclimate studies, yet many are built on assumptions now challenged by these
findings:
- Continuity:
Interrupted by hypogenic pulses.
- Closed-system
isotopic behaviour: Disrupted by radionuclide flux and
recrystallization.
- Chronology:
Obscured by uranium-series mobility and laminae overprinting.
- Microclimatic
stability: Oversimplified in systems with active diurnal ventilation.
Future studies must incorporate ventilation monitoring,
radionuclide profiling, and hypogenic event detection to validate datasets.
Without this, reconstructions may reflect post-genetic chemical noise rather
than genuine climatic shifts.
7. Conclusion
This paper highlights the need for a change in basic
assumptions in cave climatology and speleothem interpretation. By acknowledging
the roles of hypogenic overprinting, diurnal ventilation, and
radionuclide-induced speleogenesis, researchers can more accurately reconstruct
paleoenvironments and identify cave systems unsuitable for paleoclimatic
analysis.
References
Choi, D.-W., Kim, Y., & Woo, K.S., 2013. Seasonal and
diurnal variations of radon concentration in Seongryu Cave, Korea. Journal of
Environmental Radioactivity, 115, pp.73–80.
Cigna, A.A., 2005. Radon in caves. International Journal of
Speleology, 34(1–2), pp.1–18.
de Freitas, C.R. and Littlejohn, R.N., 1987. Cave climate:
Assessment of heat and moisture exchange. Journal of Climatology, 7(6),
pp.553–569.
Dorale, J.A. & Liu, Z., 2009. Limitations of
Uranium-Thorium dating of speleothems: Open-system behavior and isotopic
resetting. Quaternary Science Reviews, 28(15–16), pp.1505–1522.
Edwards, R.L., Chen, J.H. & Wasserburg, G.J., 1987.
238U–234U–230Th–232Th systematics and the precise measurement of time over the
past 500,000 years. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 81(2–3), pp.175–192.
Garagnon, J., Siffert, D., Valla, P.G. and Mattielli, N.,
2023. Ventilation regime in Milandre Cave (Switzerland): Impact on CO₂ and
microclimate. arXiv preprint arXiv:2304.12819.
Gregorič, A., Vaupotič, J., Šebela, S. and Stanič, S., 2013.
The role of cave ventilation in governing cave temperature and radon levels
(Postojna Cave, Slovenia). International Journal of Climatology, 33(6),
pp.1538–1548.
Klimchouk, A., 2007. Hypogene Speleogenesis: Hydrogeological
and Morphogenetic Perspective. National Cave and Karst Research Institute,
Special Paper 1.
Palmer, A.N., 2007. Cave Geology. Cave Books.
Sánchez-Cañete, E.P., Serrano-Ortiz, P., Kowalski, A.S. and
Domingo, F., 2013. Cave ventilation is influenced by CO₂-dependent virtual
temperature. International Journal of Speleology, 42(1), pp.1–8.
Oh, Y.H., Kim, G. Factors controlling the air ventilation of
a limestone cave revealed by 222Rn and 220Rn
tracers. Geosci J 15, 115–119 (2011).
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12303-011-0010-3
.JPG)
Comments